With approval from a few folks who answered a poll I posted...
A friend asked me yesterday if I was working on any fanfic currently. I told her that my fanfic writing tends to go in cycles; I’ll write like a demon for a while and then go dormant for a while. I’m okay with that. It is coming up on a year since I’ve written anything, and although I haven’t been inspired to write, I kind of miss it. I can at least think back on the stuff I’ve written that I’ve really loved.
Feel free to roll eyes and/or skip right through this egoist post! But here are my thoughts on my favorites of all the fanfic I’ve written.
I will also include my least favorites at the end!
First, my fanfic on the X-men as they appear in X-men: The Animated Series:
Best short and medium length fics: Set Them Free and My Year of the Tiger
Set Them Free – This one has been favorited more than any other fic of mine on ffnet. It’s a classic Rogue and Gambit story, opening with Rogue having decided that since she can never touch Gambit, she needs to tell him once and for all that their relationship is over before it begins. I think I captured the characters and some angst well, while still giving this one a believable and good ending.
My Year of the Tiger – Jubilee’s narration about a challenging year for the X-men. This one hasn’t gotten anywhere near the number of reviews or faves that the one above has and it gets off to a choppy start, but I’d still say it’s one of my best. I liked focusing on Jubilee, and I liked showing small cracks of sunlight in a very dark tale.
Best long fics: Captive Hearts and Parallels
Captive Hearts – The X-men have been captured and imprisoned – not by some dastardly foe but by the US government which judges them a threat. I liked that I decided to focus just on the men’s prison and on their anguish at being separated from the women, I liked the creepy undertones about why they are really imprisoned, I liked the conflict between the X-men and the other mutant groups in jail, and there were some twists involving a prison guard. The ending wasn’t the strongest though.
Parallels – This was a re-write or a different take on my first-ever X-men fanfic, the mammoth-sized trilogy “X-men: Friends of Humanity”. I thought this re-write was much more crisp and focused, and did better justice to the characters and their relationships. I love the classic underdog theme which gets at the heart of the X-men: protecting and sometimes just surviving in a world that fears and hates them.
Least favorite:
This one is easy.
Election Day is my least-favorite. Two main reasons:
1. Boring battle scenes (a longtime reader encouraged me to write more battle scenes, and he had a point but they weighed the fic down since my strength is just never going to be in this area), and
2. Just general failure to get at what I was aiming for: an exploration of homophobia and how it weakens a team. The exploration is there but really poorly executed.
And second big category, my favorite Azazel/Riptide fic:
I busted a shoulder and my back writing so much about them, so intensely for so many months. I am limiting myself to picking just
three fics in this category. My selections are: Hestia, Riptide in Eight Acts, and Two Halves.
Hestia – My only multi-chaptered, longish fic in the AzRi realm, and I loved how it showed their lives and relationship over time, getting in and out of trouble, etc. I also thought I did a good job of giving meaningful glimpses of other characters in the XMFC realm: Angel, Mystique, and Magneto.
Riptide in Eight Acts – This one has the most faves on ffnet, and if you add in the reviews from LJ, I think it has the most reviews of any AzRi fic. I thought it was a simple tale of a mutant’s life, going from isolation to love and community, from passivity and fear to a measure of empowerment.
Two Halves – I though this one had the most unique spin on the relationship, and I also saw it as one of the most realistic. Sounds weird to say, but when I was imagining it and writing it, the story just felt “right” or true. Also, by this point my writing had improved thanks to a few beta testers, and I think I was writing more descriptively.
Least favorite:
Mouthing Off, - It was hastily-written, when I was first coming down with the AzRi bug and just wanted to get something out there. But it did serve a purpose: it showed me that readers wanted stuff on this pairing! Reviews were shockingly-good considering how slapdash it was.